Why Am I Still Soft After 40 Even Though I Work Out?
Lab report · Your workout after 40
The Health Revival Show · EP1032
Test
Result
Flag
Walking + Pilates + 15 lb dumbbells
NORMAL
UNDER-DOSED
The real answer
If you're over 40 and still soft despite working out, your workouts are usually too light. FitMom practitioners Liz Roman and Becca Chilczenkowski explain that falling estrogen blunts muscle's response to training, and a 2026 review found lean mass 5.7% lower after menopause. Walking, Pilates and 15-pound dumbbells no longer give enough stimulus. Progressive strength training taken close to failure, two to three times a week, is what rebuilds muscle and tone.
Watch
Work with a practitioner
Lifting, eating enough, and your body still won't budge?
That's usually hormones, gut or thyroid talking. Apply for a Root Cause Discovery Call and our practitioners run the labs that find out why.
You cannot walk your way to strength.
Becca Chilczenkowski · at 12:33Full transcript
Episode transcript
Speaker-labeled and lightly edited for transcription errors. Timestamps match the episode audio.
At 00:00
Are walking and light dumbbells enough after 40?
00:00
Becca Chilczenkowski
You are over 40 and your workouts are walking and maybe you do some like little at home dumbbells and the heaviest dumbbells you have are 15 pounds. We have to talk because this is not going to get you where you want to be. It's not going to be enough.
00:12
Liz Roman
I have yet to see a woman get bulky that is eating a clean diet and strength training appropriately.
00:16
Becca Chilczenkowski
Walking is great, but walking is not going to cut it in terms of osteoporosis prevention, in terms of fracture risk, in terms of bone loss, all of these things.
00:27
Liz Roman
So even post-menopausal women with osteopenia and osteoporosis improved spine bone density with heavy lifting. Welcome back to the Health Revival Show. We are in Austin, Texas podcasting today and we've got a couple of interviews. Our practitioners are flying in from all over, which is really cool. And so we're excited to be here and knock out a few of these.
00:46
Liz Roman
I think you're going to love today's topic if you are a woman over 40 and working on your body composition, wanting to improve longevity, and I would even say agility, right? Your ability to move throughout life, extend your life span, and have a good quality of life. This is for you. For sure. And we might rub you the wrong way, or there might be some hard truths in here, maybe some little gut checks, nuggets that you're like, "Ooh!"
01:07
Liz Roman
Okay, I gotta make some changes. This is gonna be hard. Just know we love you. And this is all from the research, and sometimes the truth. It's just what you need to hear.
01:20
Becca Chilczenkowski
Yes, and when it comes to exercise, I think we can make all of the reasons, excuses, justifications that you want to make. But I always think of there is someone in a worse situation than you making it happen. And that's like, it always reminds me that things could be a lot worse. And we are not in this podcast episode telling you if you are debilitating, you know, symptoms, you can't get out like struggling to get through a day that you have to just go and lift your body weight in a squat tomorrow. Like that is not the point of this podcast.
01:52
Becca Chilczenkowski
There are definitely seasons where we pull exercise out for clients and where it is more beneficial to do less. And that is a situation of its own. Today is more just understanding the impact that muscle or lack of muscle can make on aging. And when you get to this phase of life, things have to change. And that's a reality.
02:11
Becca Chilczenkowski
Like the statistics don't lie with this. And if you are over 40 and your, you know, workouts are walking, and maybe you do some like little at home dumbbells and the heaviest dumbbells, you have are 15 pounds, we have to talk because this is not going to get you where you want to be. It's not going to be enough. It's not your fault. But your body just needs more to get some type of stimulus to produce a result that you are likely looking for.
02:36
Becca Chilczenkowski
And Liz and I both have spent many, many years, decades in a gym, managing gyms, owning gyms. We know what it takes to get quote unquote bulky. Probably ain't gonna happen for you guys Okay. It requires a lot more than you think. It requires eating much, much more.
02:53
Becca Chilczenkowski
Lifting massive amounts of weight that most of you just probably won't do so take that concern off the table for the rest of this podcast. Because the things that people want they require some pretty heavy weights that we need to have a gut check with
At 03:10
Will lifting heavy weights make women bulky?
03:10
Liz Roman
I have yet to see a woman get bulky that is eating a clean diet and strength training appropriately. The people that are getting bulky are not eating clean diets. Like, they're the ones that would show up to the gym and they would want to come twice a day. And then they would leave and go to the Mexican restaurant down the street and have margaritas and all of the things.
03:28
Becca Chilczenkowski
Okay.
03:28
Liz Roman
There's bulking in different ways here. That was a way where we're putting a lot of inflammation, water retention on. We're not purely focused on like, if you were bulking the right way, you would be getting on stage. I mean, there's a time and a place where you bulk and you lean back out.
03:45
Becca Chilczenkowski
and even those individuals
03:46
Liz Roman
It's complete
03:47
Becca Chilczenkowski
A lot of these people are on gear too guys. Like the people that you're seeing on Instagram that you're like, I don't wanna look like her. Listen to her talk, she probably has voice of a man because she's probably on some gear and they choose to do that and that's okay for them. Like that is also not something that's just gonna naturally happen for us. Okay women, believe me.
04:04
Becca Chilczenkowski
Liz and I have both been in places where like dead lifting 400 pounds, squatting 300 pounds. I was not bulky. I was cut.
04:12
Liz Roman
And I was very gay Okay.
04:14
Becca Chilczenkowski
But I was bulky for reasons. I was very muscular. I was very muscular and I had very little body fat. So you could see the muscle, but I was also lean to where people were like, "Oh, great arms." It wasn't, "Oh my God, your arms are the size of my neck."
04:28
Becca Chilczenkowski
That doesn't happen easily or naturally in most cases. So we just want to talk today around one. Let's start with kind of the hard reality. Just get it out of the way.
At 04:37
Why is it harder to build muscle during perimenopause and menopause?
04:37
Becca Chilczenkowski
You will probably have to work harder in this phase of life than any other phase of life that you have up until this point to maintain or improve a body composition. So there's actually some research in this which is interesting. There's a 2026 review so very recent. And what they found is that lean mass runs about two and a half percent lower in perimenopausal women and 5. 7% lower in postmenopausal women compared to premenopause.
05:04
Becca Chilczenkowski
That is the muscle building response to lifting and protein is now blunted. So you doing the exact same thing that you did in your 20s and 30s now gives you less of a response in your 40s and 50s. Like without ever changing anything else, you are now getting less for your return. AKA, you are going to have to work harder. That is the bottom line of that review is what they found like you are going to build muscle to prevent sarcopenia the loss of muscle to also support osteoporosis from worsening like you are going to have to work harder because estrogen too helps muscle respond to training women on estrogen therapy increased muscle protein synthesis after a hard leg workout while post menopausal women with very low estradiol showed no change another reason that these people all over the internet that are like the low estrogen proclamers.
05:58
Becca Chilczenkowski
And just take a look at them guys. The eyes look sunken in. It's estrogen is not just for the nice things. It is for literal longevity.
At 06:07
How do estrogen, testosterone and progesterone affect muscle?
06:07
Liz Roman
Yeah, and there's so much research in regards to even your gut microbiome. We've been talking a lot more about this in regards to even testosterone. I know so many people have been feared away because they think that testosterone is the male hormone. It's actually the most dominant hormone in a female's body and especially in this season and where estrogen is rapidly declining. We were talking about this in the car yesterday.
06:24
Liz Roman
Even when you're on testosterone therapy, if your estrogen is really low, you are going to have more of these DHT symptoms. You're not going to feel the best on it because you have to have estrogen all three. Think of a three-legged chair, right? Or I'm looking at a camera right now that is a tripod. If I'm missing one of those between testosterone, estrogen, progesterone, or they're imbalanced, I'm leaning, I'm falling, I'm not optimized, right?
06:46
Liz Roman
And so there was some questions that we'll get to in another Q&A, do I have to do HRT to optimize? Looking at every person's body, bioindividually is important. You may go on, for Becca and I, I can speak for both of us because this is true as it stands today. We are both on testosterone therapy. We've both had.
07:07
Liz Roman
Total testosterone below 20 since our 20s like mine was at a 13. I think my was at a seven It's wild right there was nothing there my free testosterone what I say was like point three years I have to go back and pull the labs but this is from the years of being inflamed dealing with auto immunity being on birth control like there's a lot of reasons that beyond just natural aging and the initial decline of testosterone in the 20s for females that mine was extremely low. And so I'm optimizing that right now. My estrogen is still good, my periods are still good. I have gone through phases where I've used progesterone in the postpartum phase.
07:47
Liz Roman
I'm not currently. So it's going to ebb and flow for you, but we have to look at this and this is where the mirror can come to play to really help us to say. If I want to have a strong body, muscle is the organ of longevity, then I do need to look at how I can support optimizing my hormones. You can try it, of course, through food that requires you eating enough. We're going to do a whole podcast on cortisol and stress and all of that.
08:12
Liz Roman
And there's so many factors to look at. Guys, truly is.
At 08:15
Why is stress the root of so much dysfunction?
08:15
Liz Roman
Much as we hound this on our podcast, we do it because there's no other way to get the point across that stress is the overarching theme to all dysfunction. Because it's going to destroy your microbiome and the gut lining, you're going to deplete your nutrients, your vitamin and minerals faster than anything else other than like a severe, you know, sickness or illness, right? And then your nervous system gets stuck in fight or flight, your HRV is tanking, which is essentially how your body is able to handle the stress being placed on it. Because people have said, well, what is HRV? How do I track this?
08:49
Liz Roman
Why should I care? It's like, well, this is my body's resilience that what I'm doing in my lifestyle is adaptable like my body's adapting to the demands and I was even talking a few weeks ago answering a question about it was a mom who had asked me about her 16 year old and she's training she's an athlete I don't remember what sport I think she was a swimmer or maybe a dancer but I'm like you're asking me all of these questions I mean I had little information about her health history but in terms of her symptoms I'm like. Most athletes that we see in the teens program that come in, they're far undernourished, meaning they're not eating the right types of food or the right quality and quantity together. So they're not getting the nutrients that they need. They're certainly, in most cases, not getting the amount of electrolytes and minerals that they need to keep up with the demands on their body.
09:36
Liz Roman
So there's a lot that goes into this. And so when we think about you know, aging that also comes with its own cost here. If you want to look the way that you want to look, and most people would say the word tone, lean and tone, right? We get it, but you don't get tone without building muscle. When you're bulky, you have a lot of fluff around said muscle.
09:56
Liz Roman
I had a lot of fluff around said muscle because I had muscle when I was doing the powerlifting stuff, but I was also very inflamed. So there was a lot going on there.
At 10:06
Why won't Pilates and good intentions cut it anymore?
10:06
Liz Roman
And so we just have to remember as we go through this, efforts are going to have to change. Pilates isn't going to cut it. That's just the straight, honest to God truth. It's not a punishment. It is just the reality that hard doesn't mean you have to be exhausted all the time.
10:19
Liz Roman
You also hear us as moms, business owners, people who are actively changing things in their lifestyle, trying to be mindful of us all the time. We train three to four days a week. They're about 45, maybe. 55 minute workouts because I simply don't have any more time for that. We're working to optimize and eat enough outside of it.
10:36
Liz Roman
That's something I've certainly been guilty of. It's a lot harder to put muscle on and eat enough and recover well enough than it is to fast and be lean and get skinny fat. I'm going to say I understand there are a subset of people out there who are also weight loss resistant. There's a lot of other factors that go into that statement, but even women in our practice when they go through those seasons and they come out of it and they're like, I gotta go back to eating more. I have to intentionally then prep.
11:05
Liz Roman
I have to think about cooking. I have to think about my schedule. Like it's way easier to skip meals. So much easier. That's what gets you into the situation of you won't hold the muscle, especially if you're using a GLP-1, which is a different conversation.
11:16
Liz Roman
So you just have to think about when you want to look a certain way, there is a cost and that is your effort and it is your intention. A 30 year old body cannot get away with Pilates and good intentions. Your 45 year old body cannot do that. And so this is again, not bad news, it's just new rules. It's a new decade of life.
11:33
Liz Roman
You're past your childbearing years, your hormones are declining, your estrogen's fluctuating all over the place, your gut microbiome is now telling you, hey, there's been dysfunction, it's highlighting the things that have kind of been compensated for. And so even though you could do that a decade ago, and it worked for you. This is why you're soft today and it's just physiology.
At 11:55
Is walking enough exercise for women over 40?
11:55
Becca Chilczenkowski
Yeah, and walking is great, but walking is not going to cut it in terms of osteoporosis prevention, in terms of fracture risk, in terms of bone loss, all of these things like, and the lower intensity training is not going to do it either. That's the problem guys, like I'm not saying not to do these things, but so many people when we say do you exercise or like I walk three miles a day? I'm like, "Awesome. That is exercise. That is not the type of exercise that is going to get us somewhere."
12:21
Becca Chilczenkowski
Because walking, cycling, even swimming, which is great cardiovascular exercise that is an aerobic thing, it puts customary loads on bones that just don't exceed the threshold that we need. And so you cannot walk your way to strength. And there was a study done in older women, higher activity levels narrowed the gap in mobility, but the gap in quadriceps strength and endurance widened. So the authors concluded that brisk walking will not overcome aging effects on strength, and that starting resistance training early is critical. This is where I think so many people miss the mark in terms of they wait because they got by in their 30s with doing minimal and they didn't see a negative effect and then it hits them in their 40s and they're like, well now I have to start strength training and it's so much harder to get into it when you're also struggling with energy and when you're struggling with weight gain that's happening out of nowhere and you're feeling inflamed and your joints hurt and all the like and I know if you are in that place right now and you're listening it's like well too late advice wise but.
13:23
Becca Chilczenkowski
If you are not in that place yet and you haven't fully reached, you know, that peak of perimenopause going into, you know, early onset or onset of menopause, start ASAP. Like, I am so grateful for how muscle has carried me through my life and given me a buffer that I otherwise would not have. And I see this all the time.
At 13:39
Why can fit women eat more without gaining?
13:39
Becca Chilczenkowski
And you probably know these people where like, they're pretty fit. And they seem to be able to eat what they want sometimes. And they seem to be able to drink here and there, and like it doesn't affect them as negatively. And I'm not saying to go and eat whatever you want and drink whatever you want, but like, there's a reason for that. Muscle is very metabolically forgiving.
13:59
Becca Chilczenkowski
And the more you have of it, the more forgiving it can be. And I know many women that I see that are like, I had to have my own small pizza last night, but... They're 18% body fat and they are lifting heavy, heavy weights. And sure, is that the best thing to do? Maybe not.
14:14
Becca Chilczenkowski
But their body handles it better because the muscle will use it a lot more readily in terms of the glycogen and it keeps you a lot more insulin sensitive. And we'll get into this, but like muscle in and of itself is anti-inflammatory. It is its own organ. A lot of people don't realize muscle is an organ and it kind of emits these anti-inflammatory chemicals that help combat things in the body. And so just understand that muscle can do you a lot of good.
14:44
Becca Chilczenkowski
And if you can go into this phase of life, it'll serve you.
14:50
Liz Roman
Well, I was just thinking as you were talking through that, we have been training for decades. And there are still things, we just talked about this in the car that we could improve in terms of form and technique, balance, spending time doing more mobility work, right? We were talking about our pregnancies just destroying our hip flexors and deadlifting is just not my friend anymore. And so the earlier that you get started, the more that you can also protect your body from a balanced perspective too. I think when I used to teach mobility PiYo in the gym, so it was like Pilates and yoga, it was Chalene Johnson's program, it was fun.
15:23
Liz Roman
But that is more of an assistance to helping you improve your lifts and recover from your lifts and do it safely. And that's I think is really, really important.
At 15:31
When does bone loss start in menopause?
15:31
Liz Roman
So if you think about like going into the season of life in regards to menopause and you have a retirement account, so this is the analogy that we're going to use. You're entering into a stretch where withdrawal, speed up and deposits get harder. They slow down, right? The bigger the balance going in, the longer before you go broke and hit the floor, right? So the window opens earlier than most of you think.
15:54
Liz Roman
There was a study, the SWAN study, and it found, and this is really important for bone loss Ladies. Hear this when I say what this study found and I know that Dr. Mary Claire Haver and all of these women in the space have been talking about this because we are seeing greater osteoporosis rates and risk and it's really, really hard to slow it down when you're there and it's really, really hard to gain it back when you're there. Something like minimal ability to gain it back. So the SWAN study found fast bone loss starts one year before the final period stays fast for around three years and averages 2% a year, that's roughly 10% over a decade of loss, right?
16:32
Liz Roman
And so many women are in that window before they ever even feel menopausal. So the more muscle, the longer that we can prevent this because you are doing workouts and training styles of training, hopefully activity that is going to give you bone remodeling and you're stressing and you're asking the body to bring in osteoclasts and blasts to keep your bones strong.
At 16:56
Why does muscle mass matter for longevity and blood sugar?
16:56
Liz Roman
In another study, there was 3,659 older adults. The highest quartile of muscle mass had about 20% lower all-cause mortality than the lowest. Above average can really pay off here even when we're looking at again not just living longer but having quality of life longer that life span. So each 10% increase in relative muscle mass would link to 11% lower insulin resistance. Talk about metabolic health super super important.
17:26
Liz Roman
12% lower prediabetes prevalence and the benefit held across the entire range, not just at the low end. So it's not too late to start, but every day that you delay, you're basically taking withdrawals from your life. We always say sitting is the new smoking, it's a carcinogen, right? What does that do? What do carcinogens do?
17:43
Liz Roman
They shorten our lifespan. So even postmenopausal women with osteopenia and osteoporosis improved spine bone density with heavy lifting. So there was a trial that was done here and the point is that if you keep muscle like longer, it's easier to keep it than it is to rebuild it.
At 18:00
Do you lose muscle on a GLP-1?
18:00
Liz Roman
But here's the thing with the world that we live in and so many people going on GLP-1 medications. And I've said this at nauseam and I'm going to say it again. I believe that it should be a requirement to go in and get a DEXA scan to track your muscle when you are going to utilize a GLP-1. I also believe that you should be tracking your weight trends and if you're losing more than two pounds a week they should slow you down and they should not allow you to continue to just increase the dose because many people if they're going to the provider they're getting the starting dose and then four weeks later they're doubling it. And then four weeks later they're going up.
18:36
Liz Roman
So it goes 2. 55, 7. 5, 10, 12 5. Do you think that the insurance companies care? It took cost to them, but do they care that you are basically worsening your health when you're doing this versus if you use it in a micro dose way? you actually can expand your life.
18:57
Liz Roman
And there's a lot of research and studies on this too that are showing when you lose at a slower rate, we know that we tend to, especially if you are strength training, lose less muscle. If you lose at a fast rate, you're not just losing fat, you're losing muscle. And then when you go off of it, you're rebound right back up and you're getting more fat. You're not gaining that muscle back because your ass hasn't been in the gym.
19:19
Becca Chilczenkowski
And a lot of these people that are losing all this weight on GLP-1s that are like, I lost my muscle. I think a lot of them did not have very much muscle to begin with. And they were maybe a little inflamed and they thought they had muscle because they were more overweight, fluffy. And then they're like, I lost my butt. Like I saw multiple people then they're good friends of mine and I love them dearly But they've all been on GLP-1s and they all have very flat butts and I know them and they don't lift and they don't squat heavy and they don't do these things and maybe they do like some moderate exercise But you guys I have been on a GLP Liz has been on a GLP.
19:56
Becca Chilczenkowski
I have not seen a massive decrease in muscle. I actually think my body composition got better because I was just generally inflamed and then the GLP and the very low dose that I use allowed me to just drop that inflammation so you could see the muscle a lot better but I had maintained the heavy lifting the entire time and so from the people that I have seen and I have seen a lot of clinical situations of people on GLP-1s. There's a very large difference between people that exercise regularly at heavy weights and use GLP-1s and they look phenomenal because they maintained the muscle that they kept, that they had the beginning, and then there's the other people that weren't exercising that much, that used it, that lost a bunch of weight and great, they're probably healthier in a lot of ways, but they didn't have muscle to begin with, and I think we're realizing that.
20:41
Liz Roman
And I would say there too, if you go back and look at my OMAD story, I did lose a lot of muscle because I was also fasting a lot. You were fasting a ton. It was in a very specific protocol and knowing what I know now versus then I don't know that I would have supported doing that as long as I did because it was very restrictive on the calorie piece. It was a lot of fasting. And then with that, I mean, I lost weight in a lot of inflammation.
21:06
Liz Roman
You lost it fast.
21:09
Becca Chilczenkowski
I remember.
21:10
Liz Roman
Well, when I went on [unclear], I dropped like 10 pounds of inflammation pretty quickly. Then we added the GLP-1 in and then it was, I got really small, but there was not enough emphasis on the refeed out of it. And that's one thing that I realized because obviously working with like the coach that I have now, it's been really eye opening to see how much, and again testosterone's on board and it wasn't then, this is pre-Ethan and all the things, but how much I'm able to eat and still maintain about the same weight and not use a GLP the way that I was. So, I mean, I've been there and I would say again, it is way harder to build muscle back. My story though also has a pregnancy within it and I did train throughout my pregnancy, but again, postpartum and all of that is just naturally going to influence things.
21:56
Liz Roman
I wish that I would not have utilized the GLP-1 in that particular season. I have to say
22:03
Becca Chilczenkowski
Yeah, and I think it's obviously different. There's so many different scenarios in cases. I'd remember in a lot of, like I lost 10 or 12 pounds in a month, but it was all inflammation. And it was like water coming off of me. And I didn't change anything else with what I was doing nutritionally.
22:16
Becca Chilczenkowski
I just started that low-dose GLP. And I'll see that with people that are like, they're doing everything else, right? They've done a lot of the other work. And then that's like that last little piece that, you know, can be a huge game changer for a lot of people and why we're huge fans of it in the right scenarios and in the right dosing. So back to this muscle situation and why holding a lot of muscle is very helpful.
22:40
Becca Chilczenkowski
So each 10% increase in relative muscle mass was linked to 11% lower insulin resistance and 12% lower prediabetes prevalence. And the benefit held across the whole range, not just the low end, meaning like people that are 35% body fat and then lose 10% to 25%. They see the same as someone that's 25 and goes to 15, right? So it doesn't matter like where you start at. It is a huge shift in the insulin sensitivity, which basically allows you to eat things and not have as negative a response to it, right?
At 23:09
Should women over 40 stop being afraid of carbs?
23:09
Becca Chilczenkowski
You can eat more, you can eat more carbs. All of you that are terrified of carbs out there. Like, carbs are so necessary for thyroid and recovery and muscle development and energy and cortisol. Like, if I were to pick one macronutrient that I wish people would not be afraid of it would be carbohydrates. And stop.
23:28
Becca Chilczenkowski
I eat 120 grams of protein today. I'm like, okay, how many carbs do you eat? Well, I try to limit carbs. How much fat? Oh, I don't really pay attention to that Cool.
23:38
Becca Chilczenkowski
You're probably eating 1400 calories then. Like it happened so often. And people just don't realize it or they're imbalanced, inconsistent. They're low during the week, high on the weekends, right? And so.
23:49
Liz Roman
It's types of carbs, you know, like are you having good quality carbs with fiber and antioxidants and nutrients that your body can use and burn as energy? Or are you eating cookies and Ho Hos? Like let's be honest with ourselves because most of the people who say that it's the carbs, I mean, and I can say if you go on our website, you go on my Instagram, you can look at my client, Kristen. She came in and she was on the brink of prediabetes and she was doing keto for a long time. She was very inflamed.
24:15
Liz Roman
I wouldn't call her classify her as overweight. She's very tall, but she was very inflamed and she was holding a lot in the midsection. Now she's pregnant like halfway through her pregnancy, so we can't show, you know, updated, but you see the after where, by the way, her blood sugars regulated. She's no longer prediabetic. She's not at the risk of having to take any type of medication and.
24:34
Liz Roman
She was lean and she was also doing it properly because I made her get in with a personal trainer and strength train. I was like, stop with whatever these free free workouts are. You're wasting your time. I need you lifting and I need you to get in with somebody who understands what progressive overload is. Not just go to a class that's a hit class, right?
24:55
Liz Roman
Where there's weights involved and you're getting your cardio, I understand all that and it can be fun, right? It can be fun. Progressive overload. Time under tension. Anyways, there are multiple stories that we can tell you within our practice of these situations where we're able to correct the deficiencies, bring back.
25:10
Liz Roman
And of course, there is a short period. I've been through this myself, Becca's been through it herself. We bitch to each other about it. Like let's not sit here and act like we don't complain about the water retention, but then it levels out Right? And so you can go slow to go fast in terms of slow walk your carbs up, let your body and your RAAS system and your water retention and all these things kind of level out a bit.
25:33
Liz Roman
Let your gut start to catch back up because again, when people are going on these keto carnivore diets, they're typically not eating adequate levels. I mean, Americans in general, 5% of Americans eat adequate fiber. So those who are doing keto carnivore absolutely aren't eating the adequate levels that we want, which is really upper 40, 45 grams, even more for some individuals. And so if you think about that diverse microbiome, if you had all the proper microbes and gastric juices and things happening in your gut, you can break these things down, you have minimal bloating and reactions and your water retention shouldn't be strong. In fact, you'll notice over time that it gets way better and you'll look way better because you're going to look fuller and not so just flat.
26:17
Liz Roman
And that's what you see is a lot of people walking around, not only do they have a flat ass but they got flat cheeks, their faces sunk it in, their eyes are looking like they haven't slept in months and it's not because they're not sleeping, they are malnourished.
26:32
Becca Chilczenkowski
Yep. So when we have adequate muscle, obviously we have better blood sugar handling. That's number one. It's kind of like a little get out of jail free card with heavy lifting. It does things that cardio can't and I'm not saying don't do cardio.
26:44
Becca Chilczenkowski
Like I cardio still is the king when it comes to cardiovascular health. Like if you have health history in your family of heart attacks, strokes, anything related to, you know, calcium buildup, things like that. 100% cardiovascular work is necessary and very helpful. But that can be like walking at an incline for 30 minutes a day. It doesn't need to be you go out and run, right?
27:06
Becca Chilczenkowski
That's not necessarily need in these cases.
At 27:09
How heavy should women over 40 lift?
27:09
Becca Chilczenkowski
But with muscle, it just does more when it comes to long-term benefit when it comes to investment in longevity and all the things that you can benefit from it just pays dividends and so let's quantify this like how heavy how often what does the research say is necessary a meta analysis of 21 studies and this is interesting found heavy loads produced greater gains in max strength. But muscle growth was actually similar across light and heavy loads. When sets went to failure. So what does this mean essentially? You could be lifting really heavy for a max set of six or you can be lifting a little bit more moderately heavy for a set of 12 to 15.
27:53
Becca Chilczenkowski
As long as both sets are going to near failure, you will see similar strength which is the concept of like hypertrophy versus max lifting, right? It's just, it's a little bit different in terms of how it's going to be set up, the number of reps you're going to do per set, the rest periods between sets, right? It kind of depends on what you're going for. I actually prefer hypertrophy. I find that it leads to less injuries.
28:15
Becca Chilczenkowski
I mean, like getting under max loads and going for like a one rep max or a three rep max is really taxing on not only joints and ligaments but also on the nervous system like a lot of people don't realize how Intense for your actual nervous system a one-rep max deadlift can be like it can wipe you and I know because Liz and I have both been down that road many many years It's awful like and also at that load your comp you're starting to compensate like other muscle groups get involved that necessarily shouldn't be and so like I'm a time and a place, right? If you're trying to train for a competition, if you're trying to train for a performance situation, by all means, yeah, I think that they could be very beneficial and necessary. But if you're just trying to train to look good and feel good, which at this point in my life, that's what I'm here for, you don't need that. You just really don't. You can get the same benefit from six to eight reps, eight to 12, 12 to 15 reps.
29:02
Becca Chilczenkowski
But I will say Light weights probably aren't gonna build muscle like it's not many people are gonna get to a true failure and build muscle with like a five pound set of dumbbells or a ten pound set of dumbbells unless you're doing like lateral raises which also burn which are so bad and then in terms of failure, right?
At 29:18
What does training to failure actually mean?
29:18
Becca Chilczenkowski
This is something that can be scary for a lot of people and in all honestly I don't think many women get here I don't think many women have been taught what true failure feels like or looks like I don't think that many people mentally have been able to get themselves to go there. I mean, I'll be honest, like at this point in life, I struggle to even get there because I'm like, this burns, it hurts. I don't have a reason to really need to max out right now, but I've been taught how to train hard and I know what that feels like. And so I have a comparison, right? whereas a lot of people haven't been taught by a really qualified trainer. Someone that knows what they're doing has been taught proper form, knows how to engage the right muscle groups, right?
29:56
Becca Chilczenkowski
There's a lot to it that I think people discount and don't fully comprehend. And so I do think that there is a large benefit to finding a gym, a trainer for even a short period of time or someone online. There's a lot of great online people out there that you can send form videos to that can help you virtually, that can help you understand are you engaging the right things? Does this look like this person's going to failure? Right? I got a huge training age under my belt.
30:21
Becca Chilczenkowski
Like, and when we say training age, it means like, what is your true experience with training hard? I have been lifting heavy since my early twenties. That is almost two decades. I still get critiqued by my coach in terms of like you had a lot more in the tank with that set or hey, you know, set up yourself here because you're doing it a little bit wrong and you're engaging the wrong muscle groups, right? So the other piece about getting under a bar because I think this is important too when we're talking about like true bone density fracture prevention you know, the strengthening of joints and ligaments and all of that.
At 30:50
Can heavy lifting improve bone density with osteoporosis?
30:50
Becca Chilczenkowski
Postmenopausal women with low bone mass did 30-minute twice weekly supervised sessions. Five sets of five. It's like the Russian method, right? Five by fives. At over 85% of their max.
31:00
Becca Chilczenkowski
So basically you went to a one-rep max, you calculate 85% of that, and then you do five sets of five at that, which is actually a really intense way of training. We used to do this and I had the best results.
31:13
Liz Roman
Oh, yeah. Art would program this and we would do eight to 12 week blocks. And it was so methodical, but that's him. I mean, he is just a genius when it would come to this stuff. And we would track it.
31:24
Liz Roman
So we had a software at our gym, Wodify. And we would, the first week was find your one rep max. That set the stage in the bar. So you knew what your targets were every week and the coach before class would put it up on the board. That's what we're talking about, attention to detail and accountability.
31:40
Liz Roman
And if you missed, you're not just trying to come in two weeks later and take massive jumps because that's how people get injured. And so you can do this and be really methodical with it. And for me, I'm the type of person who is competitive. If you guys don't know that, or can't guess that about me. I liked having that target compared to what I don't love in most of the apps that I've utilized, at least with coaches online recently.
32:00
Liz Roman
I'm tracking it, but it's not necessarily giving me like, hey, today, if someone tells me today, this is what you need to be doing. No, it tells me like last week and I got to dig through the information. So then I don't necessarily do that.
32:17
Becca Chilczenkowski
But I kind of know where I'm at Yeah Yep.
32:20
Liz Roman
I think we were talking about in the car too. I'm like, okay, for people, training to failure, what does that mean? I'll just say what it means for me and obviously continue the segment. It means I have paused, I've slowed down, I've taken a 10 to 15 seconds rest and I've properly inhaled, which is very hard mentally to do 'cause sometimes I just get through it. You're bracing and you're going after that and you're like, I can do it.
32:40
Liz Roman
I have these little mantras, like you can do it, you got this, whatever. Then I fail I don't get it I miss the lift right so if you're doing a something like a squat You need to either have safety bars or someone there with you as a spotter But I was thinking about this because last Friday or whatever day it was I went in and I was doing hip thrust and I just got stuck Okay, set it down I knew and then I'm getting up and I am kind of walking like a giraffe for like a few steps there that's failure. Right would you agree like you tried and you attempted and you just couldn't do it Yeah, and then you maybe give yourself two or three minute rest and you could go back and try again I did that a few weeks ago with my squat because I was testing my one-rep max just because I wanted to not because my coach told me to but I was like where am I? Because in my mind I compared to the time I got 275 to like I'm at 185 right now, you know, and I'm like, God, you're so weak. In reality, it's not that weak, but to me, it's like, okay, I want to get back over 200 because that's what I want to be targeting and is what she just said.
33:39
Liz Roman
Whether it's five by five or it's an eight, six, four, you know, progression that you're going down week over week and increase your weight, I want to know what my target is. If I don't know my target, I have nothing to wait again.
33:56
Becca Chilczenkowski
Yeah, and getting under a barbell is kind of what I was talking through in this part in terms of with five by fives, they were doing back squats. But what they found is that spine bone density rose 2. 9% versus it dropped in the low intensity home group. So the people that are like just doing at home workouts with their dumbbells, again, better than nothing, right? Absolutely. But bone density actually dropped in that group, 1 2%.
34:18
Becca Chilczenkowski
So it's like a 4% difference in spine density, which when you're talking about, you know, protecting yourself long term and falling and not fracturing things like that makes a huge difference. And so in terms of where you can go from here, right, the home workout era is convenient, right? You can do dumbbells at home, you can. Fit it in with your kids walking around and crawling around and it can be done in 30 minutes. And it is better than nothing.
34:44
Becca Chilczenkowski
But if you are truly trying to make a drastic change to body composition to your overall health and longevity, I think that supervision for at least some period of time is going to get you way better results.
At 34:55
Do I need a personal trainer to lift heavy after 40?
34:55
Becca Chilczenkowski
Because even in research, a meta analysis found that supervised training beat unsupervised training for strength and power in older adults and recommended that two of every three weekly sessions be supervised. That was 65 plus though. Those are people are older, right? Heavy was safe because it was coached. I am very hesitant to do super heavy lifting at this point because I am by myself in a globo gym, but.
35:18
Becca Chilczenkowski
If I were to get into that again, I would want to be a gym environment where there were coaches, there were people that could spot me, there were people that I could trust because it is scary. I realized that it is not fun to get under a barbell and be like, I am going to give literally every ounce of energy in my body and every muscle group is gonna be engaged and I might fail this and the barbell can crush me and like that's not something I wanna do by myself. You know, you need a different mindset, you need supervision, you need the help. And a community is very helpful for showing up and pushing yourself. Like, I miss the days of having training partners that push me.
35:51
Becca Chilczenkowski
I really do because I am by myself for 45 minutes where my mind is typically distracted on business and other things.
36:00
Liz Roman
I'm on Instagram, you're
36:01
Becca Chilczenkowski
I remember. 1,000% Voice memoing each other Yes. And so like, I miss those days because absolutely I got better results than those days 'cause I was pushed harder. It is just the reality of it.
At 36:09
How many days a week should women over 40 strength train?
36:09
Becca Chilczenkowski
So if you are right now doing nothing, I would give yourself a goal two to three times a week. You guys, we can all fit it in. We can, I promise you. Liz and I, could I probably do more? I would probably have to sacrifice some stuff for sure.
36:25
Becca Chilczenkowski
But I could do more if I really needed to. Right now though, three times a week, 45 to 60 minutes, I think anyone can find that time. And if that means that it's at home at first, get yourself one of those adjustable set of dumbbells that go up to 100 pounds right? You can go from five pounds to my brother had those I need to buy them. They're amazing.
36:42
Becca Chilczenkowski
They're like these little clips and you can do half pounds and you can do increments and they're amazing and start with that or start with you know, a at a globo gym, machines because they're a lot more protective. You're not going to hurt yourself on a machine as easily. Things like quad extensions and you know, pulling machines and all of those. That's what I do because the years of stress from CrossFit and hundreds of millions of reps probably. My joints are just not what they used to be, I'll be totally honest.
37:07
Becca Chilczenkowski
And could I spend time fixing them? Probably, I don't though. And so I just avoid. And I lift in machines that keep me healthy and keep me safe and injury free. And then I go and pull my hip flexor kicking a soccer ball with my eight year old son.
37:20
Becca Chilczenkowski
But you know, it's. You can start somewhere and if you know that you are the type of person that needs the accountability, hire a coach, hire a personal trainer, get the accountability until you can do it on your own because there's no judgment here. If you are that type of person, realize it and set yourself up for success, I am luckily someone that can go and push myself into gym on my own. My husband is not and so he has to go to a class. He goes to a CrossFit gym, he likes it, he has his little group of 40 year old males that all are all friends and they go at 6 a m and they have their group text message and their
37:56
Liz Roman
I love it.
37:58
Becca Chilczenkowski
I know, I love it. It makes me so happy. And he came home and he was like, I snatched 240 pounds today. I was like, look at you.
38:05
Liz Roman
There's something about being in that environment where there's community and even for example, you were saying on the way here, you're like, man, I just miss running. And I was thinking like, I just don't enjoy running. Like I just, I've never have unless I'm doing it for a purpose of like playing a sport, soccer or pickle ball, like I'll go through. I mean, that's not running, but you're, you know, constantly moving or whatever. It's not my jam, right?
38:26
Liz Roman
But to each their own, when I was at the gym after, or like, you know, the gym we owned, we would go and we would run the track, it's about a mile, or the other gym that we joined after we closed it, we would go and run and we would bitch and complain and we didn't want to do it, but we would still do it because we were with everybody doing it, right? And it would push you because you don't want to be last. And I miss that environment.
At 38:45
What should I expect when I start lifting again?
38:45
Liz Roman
What I want to say to those of you who are just starting out is that it's going to suck. You're going to be sore. You're going to wake up and be like, I don't want to go today. I want to roll over in my cozy bed because it might be cold wherever you are in the morning time right now. And I get it.
39:01
Liz Roman
But at the end of the day, if you desire to become a person that you are not, then you have to make the changes. And so if you decide ahead of time and you make that commitment, these are the days and the times and you have an accountability buddy or partner, it could be somebody online. It doesn't have to be somebody in person. I think that's even better. If you can do that.
39:16
Liz Roman
Just know you will leave feeling really accomplished and then probably really really sore and you're gonna try to sit on the toilet and you're like, "Oh my God, I don't know." And it will get better over time. You will need to focus on your hydration. You will need to focus on adequate nourishment, creatine, protein, carbohydrates. All of these things can be very helpful for that recovery.
39:37
Liz Roman
Walk in between stretch, focus on mobility, get into an Epsom salt bath, do cold therapy. There's a lot of things that you can do to support recovery. But at the same token, my number one advice, because this is what I do to myself and I eat it every time, don't expect if you used to train and you're coming back to it because you're now inspired by this podcast that you'll be where you were before because what will happen there is you will try to lift the way that you did before and then you'll be really sore and regretting that for multiple days. So just embrace the suck. There's a really good book that we actually used to give to our gym members called embrace the suck.
40:18
Liz Roman
And he would talk about in there when you're in that moment of that one rep max, you need to start focusing on those mantras and visualization. Visualize yourself lifting and nailing that lift and things will go a lot better than you being, you know, uh, what was me? I'm so weak. I can't do this. I can't do this.
40:36
Liz Roman
You all can do it. You may need a bit more coaching and guidance to help you stay the course and or to help you correct the physicality of your body and. You know, this is one thing that my husband used to do and it's going to sound weird when I describe it, but he was always very cautious. I mean, we had an all women's gym. So he would first ask permission.
40:56
Liz Roman
Can I guide you here and touch you? Is it okay? Is it appropriate? But he would poke and our other Russian trainer. She was so awesome.
41:03
Liz Roman
When they would come by and I remember we'd be doing Russian kettle swings and she'd come by and she'd poke my glute. Boom, it's activation that you will never get on your own. And if you can't afford to do this longer term, then maybe, you know, just do two or three, four sessions with someone as a personal trainer who's really good in this category and ask them to get that activation with you. Because a lot of you may not know what that muscle firing feels like or it's been a really long time. And so if I had to say one last thing about this is just always be bracing.
41:35
Liz Roman
Think about when you get under these challenging loads and you're going to go for more weight than you have, get your core tight. Hold that breath. Get the breath that you need to so that you can be braced and then exhale when appropriate. And these are things that people will need to teach you and it's much easier in person. But when you get that poke, that activation, it changes the game.
41:59
Liz Roman
You not only get stronger, but you're not compensating as much as Becca talked about because he absolutely, I remember I used to try to prep for the powerlifting and deadlifting and my coach when I would send her my videos she would make me go back and repeat different things in weeks and do different angles because she could see that compensation. So it's very hard to find somebody that's really, really good at this. Do your due diligence. Don't find somebody that's just fresh out of college, though, the cheapest trainer in the gym and they're going to stand there and count your reps. Don't do that.
42:30
Liz Roman
They're distracted. That's not a good trainer. You need somebody that can help you learn to do this on your own. And in fact, I would tell a trainer, my goal is to get so much out of my time with you in these next four to six sessions because I can't stay with you weekly. Maybe other people can financially.
42:46
Liz Roman
I can't. So my goal is that you are going to give me all of the tools that I need for at least the next 12 weeks to go and run a cycle. And then maybe I'll come back and do a couple check in sessions with you and then go and do another 12 week cycle. But if you've not learned how to lift, that is step one. And then you just got to mentally prime your body and your mind to know it's going to suck.
43:07
Liz Roman
So embrace the suck. It's going to be worth it. And I hope that you enjoyed this episode. If you did, don't forget to rate, review, subscribe, share the show. And if you are somebody who is needing help with your health journey, you want to understand where your labs are.
43:21
Liz Roman
Maybe there is dysfunction going on and this feels so far out and you need help. Links are in the show notes, book a free consult with our team and with that. I hope you have a fantastic day.
Quick answers
Frequently asked questions
Is walking enough exercise for women over 40?
Not for muscle or bone. FitMom hormone specialist Becca Chilczenkowski explains that walking, cycling and swimming are great cardio, but the loads they put on bone never cross the threshold that triggers bone remodeling. Keep walking for heart health, then add progressive resistance training two to three times a week. In the LIFTMOR trial, women on a low-intensity home program lost spine bone density.
How heavy should women over 40 lift to build muscle?
Heavy enough that the last reps of every set are a real struggle. A 2017 meta-analysis of 21 studies (Schoenfeld et al.) found muscle growth was similar with lighter or heavier loads when sets went to failure, while heavier loads built more maximum strength. FitMom's Becca Chilczenkowski says most women never reach true failure with 5 or 10 pound dumbbells, so the load has to climb: roughly six to 15 reps, taken close to failure.
Will lifting heavy weights make women bulky?
Almost never. FitMom co-founder Liz Roman, a former gym owner, says she has yet to see a woman get bulky while eating a clean diet and strength training appropriately. Building large amounts of muscle takes a big calorie surplus and years of extreme loads. What most women call bulk is inflammation and water retention sitting over muscle. Bring the inflammation down and the same muscle reads as lean and toned.
Why is it harder to build muscle during perimenopause and menopause?
Because estrogen helps muscle respond to training. A 2026 narrative review in the Journal of Cachexia, Sarcopenia and Muscle found lean mass about 2.5% lower in perimenopausal and 5.7% lower in postmenopausal women than before menopause, and reported that muscle-building responses to lifting and protein may be blunted. FitMom's Becca Chilczenkowski puts it plainly: the same workouts you did at 30 return less at 45, so the effort has to go up.
When does bone loss start in menopause?
Earlier than most women expect. The Study of Women's Health Across the Nation (SWAN) found bone loss accelerates about one year before the final menstrual period and stays fast until roughly two years after it, averaging around 2.5% a year at the lumbar spine. FitMom co-founder Liz Roman notes that many women are inside that window before they ever feel menopausal, which is why heavy lifting should start in perimenopause.
Can heavy lifting improve bone density if you have osteopenia or osteoporosis?
Yes, when it is supervised. In the LIFTMOR trial, postmenopausal women with low bone mass did two 30-minute supervised sessions a week of five sets of five at over 85% of their one-rep max. Lumbar spine bone density rose 2.9%, while a low-intensity home exercise group lost 1.2%. FitMom's Becca Chilczenkowski stresses the coaching: heavy lifting was safe in that study because every session was supervised.
Why does muscle mass matter for longevity and blood sugar?
Muscle is metabolic insurance. In a UCLA analysis of national NHANES III data, each 10% increase in relative muscle mass was linked to 11% lower insulin resistance and 12% lower prediabetes prevalence. A separate UCLA study of 3,659 older adults found the highest muscle-mass group had about 20% lower all-cause mortality than the lowest. FitMom's practitioners call muscle the organ of longevity.
Do you lose muscle on a GLP-1, and how do you prevent it?
You can, especially when weight comes off fast without strength training. FitMom co-founder Liz Roman recommends a baseline DEXA scan to track muscle before starting a GLP-1, and treats losing more than about two pounds a week as a signal to slow down rather than raise the dose. Becca Chilczenkowski sees a clear split in practice: women who keep lifting heavy hold their muscle, and many who 'lost muscle' had little to begin with.
What does training to failure actually mean?
Failure means you attempt another rep with good form and cannot complete it. FitMom co-founder Liz Roman describes it as pausing, breathing, bracing, trying again, and missing the lift. Use safety bars or a spotter for squats and presses. FitMom's Becca Chilczenkowski says most women have never been taught what true failure feels like, which is why light dumbbells rarely build meaningful muscle.
How many days a week should women over 40 strength train?
Two to three to start. FitMom's Becca Chilczenkowski recommends two to three sessions a week of 45 to 60 minutes, and both hosts train three to four days a week around kids and businesses. Begin on machines or adjustable dumbbells that go up to 100 pounds, and get coached for at least a few sessions. A 2017 meta-analysis found supervised training beat unsupervised training for strength in older adults.
Glossary
Key terms
- Sarcopenia
- Age-related loss of muscle mass and strength. It speeds up across the menopause transition and is a major driver of frailty and falls.
- Anabolic resistance
- A blunted muscle-building response to lifting and protein. It is why the same workout returns less muscle at 45 than it did at 30.
- Osteopenia
- Bone density lower than normal but not yet in the osteoporosis range (DEXA T-score between -1.0 and -2.5).
- Osteoporosis
- Bone density low enough to sharply raise fracture risk (DEXA T-score of -2.5 or lower).
- Bone remodeling
- The constant cycle in which osteoclasts break down old bone and osteoblasts build new bone. Heavy loading signals the body to build.
- Progressive overload
- Gradually increasing weight, reps or sets over time so the body keeps getting a reason to adapt.
- Training to failure
- Performing a set until another rep with good form is not possible. Sets near failure drive muscle growth at light or heavy loads.
- Hypertrophy
- Muscle growth. Usually trained in the 6 to 15 rep range, as opposed to maximal strength work at one to three reps.
- One-rep max (1RM)
- The heaviest weight you can lift once with good form. Programs such as 5x5 at 85% are calculated from it.
- DEXA scan
- A low-dose X-ray that measures bone density and body composition, including lean mass, fat mass and visceral fat.
- Insulin sensitivity
- How well cells respond to insulin. Muscle is the largest site of glucose disposal, so more muscle generally means better blood sugar handling.
- Myokines
- Signaling molecules released by working muscle, several of which have anti-inflammatory effects. The reason muscle is described as an organ.
- Training age
- How many years of genuinely hard, well-coached training you have, as opposed to your chronological age.
- HRV (heart rate variability)
- Variation in time between heartbeats. Higher HRV generally reflects better stress resilience and recovery.
Research cited
Sources
- Menzies et al. (2026). Menopause, muscle mass and muscle protein turnover: a narrative review. Journal of Cachexia, Sarcopenia and Muscle. Read the study →
- Greendale et al. (2012). Bone mineral density loss in relation to the final menstrual period: SWAN. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research. Read the study →
- Watson et al. (2018). High-intensity resistance and impact training improves bone mineral density in postmenopausal women with osteopenia and osteoporosis: the LIFTMOR trial. JBMR. Read the study →
- Srikanthan & Karlamangla (2011). Relative muscle mass is inversely associated with insulin resistance and prediabetes. JCEM. Read the study →
- Srikanthan & Karlamangla (2014). Muscle mass index as a predictor of longevity in older adults. American Journal of Medicine. Read the study →
- Schoenfeld et al. (2017). Strength and hypertrophy adaptations between low- vs. high-load resistance training: a meta-analysis. JSCR. Read the study →
- Lacroix et al. (2017). Effects of supervised vs. unsupervised training programs on balance and muscle strength in older adults. Sports Medicine. Read the study →
Your hosts
Meet your hosts
Liz Roman
@thepoopqueen
Co-founder · Gut health
Former gym owner who fixes the gut first, because that's where the bloating, fatigue and stubborn weight usually start.
Follow on Instagram
Becca Chilczenkowski
@thehormonequeen
Co-founder · Hormones
Two decades under a barbell and a practice built on the labs most doctors call "normal."
Follow on InstagramYour next step
Your labs came back "normal." You still don't feel normal.
Apply for a Root Cause Discovery Call with the FitMom practitioner team.
Apply nowThis episode and page are for education only and are not medical advice. Talk with your doctor before starting a new training program, especially if you have osteopenia, osteoporosis or another medical condition. Individual results vary.
Follow on Apple
Follow on Spotify
Subscribe on YouTube