Skip to content

Is Protein Making You Gain Weight?

The Health Revival Show · Episode answer

150 g protein a day, lifting 5x a week, still gainingNORMAL
What's actually going onSTRESS STATE

Protein rarely makes you gain weight on its own. Your stress state decides what happens to it. FitMom practitioners Liz Roman and Becca Chilczenkowski explain that high cortisol and insulin resistance keep the liver converting amino acids, including ones pulled from your own muscle, into glucose through gluconeogenesis. Stack more protein on top of under-eating, low carbs, and poor digestion, and fat loss stalls while muscle quietly drops.

Doing everything right and still gaining?

If you're hitting your protein, lifting, tracking every gram, and your body won't respond, it's time to test, not guess. Our practitioners find what's keeping you stuck.

Apply for a Root Cause Discovery Call

Full episode transcript

Liz Roman (@thepoopqueen) and Becca Chilczenkowski (@thehormonequeen) of FitMom break down when protein helps, when it backfires, and why a stressed body can turn protein, and your own muscle, into sugar. Lightly edited for readability.

Can protein really be the villain?

00:00 Becca Chilczenkowski: 170 grams of protein a day. It was a lot, and I could not get inflammation off.

00:05 Liz Roman: Eating 800 calories a day, months on end and not losing weight. Maybe they're gaining weight. Well, that mathematically doesn't make sense.

00:12 Becca Chilczenkowski: I was unable to kind of fix my metabolism being totally jacked up until I went low.

00:20 Liz Roman: Protein protein could be the villain. You just haven't considered it yet.

Why the 1-gram-per-pound rule needs nuance

00:23 Becca Chilczenkowski: Welcome back to the health revival show. We are talking protein today and this is a little bit of my story, I think a little bit more me than you of I was unable to kind of fix my metabolism being totally jacked up until I went low protein. And it is a very concerning area for a lot of our clients are like, I don't want to lose my muscle. I'm afraid if I go low protein it is, I think, a misunderstood situation. And we're not saying forever, you don't have to go low protein forever, but sometimes the super high protein push the, you know, every perimenopause person on the Internet telling you that you need one gram per pound of body weight to be able to lose weight and gain muscle like we need to talk the nuance here, because there is absolutely nuance.

01:12 Becca Chilczenkowski: And I think a lot of people listening probably have been in that boat of like, you're doing everything right and you're lifting and you're hitting your protein goals and you're tracking every gram in your app and you're eating chicken and egg whites and Greek. Oh, my God, I want to vomit. Thinking about just eating egg whites.

01:28 Liz Roman: And I do too. So my coach put in some egg whites for me and I'm just the person. And it's like, Yeah, Costco, whatever. I have not touched more than one carton in like a month, and I think I'm just going to throw all these. I don't like them. Like, I just we are probably scarred from the years that we ate and we tried to make it okay. That's the thing. It's like, well, I'll just spice it up with some herbs and some hot sauce and it won't be that bad. And it's like you're just telling yourself as straight, like as this tastes like.

01:56 Becca Chilczenkowski: Crap and it's like you have to make it basically almost overdone or else it's watery and like, runny and it's just awful. And you do all of this and you're still bloated by 2 p.m. and you're gaining weight and you feel like you're kind of, you know, this brick is sitting in your stomach. We talked to a lot of women. They're like, I feel like this lump is just sitting in my stomach right? And we see these people every week in our practice. Like this is exactly the clientele

Can protein make you fat?

02:21 Becca Chilczenkowski: that comes in. And so what we want to talk about is kind of this claim, because I think it's coming to the surface a little bit more of does protein make you fat? Cannot make you fat, right? And in a stressed, inflamed body where the liver is kind of stuck pumping out glycogen, turning protein into sugar, that sugar gets stored as belly fat like it can. It absolutely can not. in every case. We're going to talk about the it depends situation, but the way that this happens is known as something called gluconeogenesis.

02:54 Becca Chilczenkowski: So we want you guys kind of understand this concept. It is gluconeogenesis basically is making new glucose. It's how your liver and to a lesser extent your kidneys build sugar from non sugar sources. So amino acids from protein plus lactate and glycerol from fat breakdown, most amino acids can be converted to glucose this way. So the real question isn't whether protein can become sugar, it's what controls that dial, because the answer is your hormones.

03:27 Becca Chilczenkowski: It's your hormones again, guys, it's the hormones. So let's talk about kind of when this happens, a little bit of research because we want to talk about these, you know, a couple of different research examples, but that is how it can happen. There is a process in the body that does this. Yes.

Is protein maxing actually healthy?

03:42 Liz Roman: But when I have something to say on this, too, because if you look at the trends, my God, it's like the fiber maxing trend, the eat everything protein, put protein in everything trend. Right. It's going to be like protein water. Now, the shakes weren't enough. Now we got to put it in the water and look.

04:01 Becca Chilczenkowski: At this protein water. That is a thing.

04:02 Liz Roman: It does, I'm telling you. Yes.

04:04 Becca Chilczenkowski: Yes. Okay.

04:05 Liz Roman: It is a thing I like. And actually, I was talking to you. So this is going to be a shameless plug for it's an Austin-based gluten-free company. And I see her every Saturday at the farmer's market because New Braunfels farmer's market is better than I said, apparently. I don't know. But she's awesome and I was talking to her last week and she said, Hey, you know, I was at a conference and I was thinking about you because they were talking about these fiber maxing things, you know?

04:33 Liz Roman: And then we got on the topic of protein and it's crazy. But if you look at the protein waters and she's telling me this right, she's like, it's all artificial. And I'm like, Yes, yes, I know. But it's funny when people like, see it and they realize, okay, we've just protein is chicken, Protein is steak. Protein is beef. Right. We're talking about good quality protein. Yes. We can get into your powders in a way, and all of these types of things that can be helpful to fill the gaps sometimes.

05:03 Liz Roman: But I certainly think and I know for myself, I have overdone it on all the added protein between bars and shakes and putting in every single thing that I made that that is not normal. So we have to sometimes stop and wonder, is fiber maxing normal? Is protein maxing normal because it's really not. If you are able to eat well-rounded meals with a diverse diet, you should be able to get the nutrients that you need without having to buy 29 different types of protein beyond animal meat. That's one ingredient to get your needs and for the day.

05:38 Liz Roman: But anyways, I digress. Neither one of them is great, right? Because if you overdo either side of it, your body is going to have a response. And so we have to question with anything whether it's protein maxing or fiber maxing, how is the body going to process this? And so that depends upon the state that your body is in and the hormones.

What happens to protein in a calm body vs. a stressed one?

05:55 Liz Roman: So in a calm, well-fed body, in healthy individuals, this process plays a relatively minor role in terms of turning protein into glucose. So researchers tracked labeled egg protein 23 grams. The body made about 50 grams of glucose over 8 hours. But only four grams came from the eggs. So the rest of that was burned as fuel or built into tissue. This is ideal in a stressed body. Cortisol turns that dial up, so cortisol switches on the liver's sugar making enzyme and also breaks down muscle to supply the amino acids for it.

06:32 Liz Roman: So under excess cortisol, larger amounts of amino acids leave muscle and get converted into glucose in the liver in an insulin resistant body. The brake is broken. So insulin normally shuts off glucose or insulin normally shuts gluconeogenesis off. After you eat an insulin resistance. The liver keeps making sugar anyway, and about 90% of that extra sugar the liver puts out comes from gluconeogenesis. Now, in a body on a low carb diet, more of your protein gets used for sugar.

07:06 Liz Roman: So fasting or a low carbohydrate diet, as much amino acid carbon as possible goes towards gluconeogenesis. This, some researchers estimate around 17 to 19% of the protein you eat can end up as glucose.

When does short-term protein restriction make sense?

07:19 Liz Roman: And so this is really where when we look at the person coming in, I was just talking to a client about this this morning. We sometimes have to go short-term protein restriction, so we need to give the body a break, focus on other fuel sources such as fat and then bring that protein back in or carbs depending upon which way you're going. Then bring that protein back in. And I have taken people down to as low as 15 grams of protein for a few days, a couple of weeks back to back. We do re feeds in between, but generally it's a 24 hour excuse me, a 48 to 72 hour protein restricted diet followed by a re feed back into that for a few cycles to help the body.

08:03 Liz Roman: Recently I did this and it worked beautifully and they had to do it for two weeks. So, Becca, obviously you shared your story. You had to do it much longer. This is something that people don't often think about because we are told protein is going to be good for us to help our sleep, our blood sugar. Right. But we're telling you something different now and it all goes back to the state of inflammation and stress now.

Does protein turn into belly fat?

08:26 Becca Chilczenkowski: So when we're asking the question like, does sugar become belly fat? Not directly, right? Gluconeogenesis says make sugar to keep your blood sugar up, not to store fat. The belly fat link is kind of more the hormone pattern around it. So cortisol plus high blood sugar plus the extra insulin needed to deal with it is the pattern that's tied to visceral, fat, fatty liver, muscle loss, all of those thing. So yes, your body can turn protein into sugar.

08:52 Becca Chilczenkowski: That's the gluconeogenesis. But protein doesn't decide how much cortisol insulin resistance under eating those, decide how much and when your diet doesn't supply the protein, cortisol will take it from your muscle. This is how under eating turns into you gaining weight and losing muscle mass. The stress of under eating, the stress of trying to work out without enough resources and nourishment. That is what leads to this. So it's not your protein that turns into belly fat.

09:18 Becca Chilczenkowski: That's not what we're saying here. It's the stress that turns protein, including your muscle into sugar to keep the body fueled. Right. So in a lot of these situations, we see women will like, oh, I'll just double my protein. Right. But they're still under eating overall or they're eating super low carb. This is what we see a lot. They're like, Well, I eat a lot of protein.

09:38 Becca Chilczenkowski: And I'm like, Well, how many calories do you eat? Do you enough carbs do enough fats? Are you choosing one or the other to focus on? Like most women are just eating low carb, high protein, low fat because they're thinking, oh, more protein, more protein, but I don't want carbs because carbs make me fat. But I don't think to eat more fat because that's something that I was demonized when I was growing up. Right. Like, so we end up in this place where also a lot of times they're eating protein, but they can't digest it because they don't have enough stomach acid.

10:03 Becca Chilczenkowski: They're doubling protein, but they're waking up at 5 a.m. unbroken sleep to go work out and they're having caffeine instead of breakfast at a job and kids and all of these things. Right. So protein got sold as like the answer because. Yes, muscle mass and muscle matters. Of course it does. Muscle is more metabolically active. Muscle, I believe, is probably when I think of like top three things for longevity and health, sleepHolding adequate muscle. I can't decide on the last one yet.

10:31 Becca Chilczenkowski: I'll think about it. But those are top two. Like absolutely top two. I'm like hydration system beast and fast like I think more of like habits, right? Like going through periods of eating enough and then fasting or under, you know, lower calorie intake. But I think sleep and muscle mass take the top two spots because it is so protective to you. Right. And so protein is a building material, though it's not a fix.

10:57 Becca Chilczenkowski: And bricks don't build a house if the construction crew like ain't working right. You know So protein is the building block. It's not a magic pill. You cannot protein a stressed out body. Right. Your protein isn't the problem. The liver, how it's responding to it is. And so we need to look at the cortisol and blood sugar piece, because when cortisol rises, blood sugar rises and the liver releases that stored sugar and that keeps you in the fight or flight.

How gut infections and mold keep you burning sugar

11:21 Becca Chilczenkowski: And we also have talked about on many other podcasts, your immune system will keep you stuck in this sugar burning state too. So if you have, you know, GI distress, if you have an autoimmune that's not being managed, if you have SIBO, if you have a chronic viral issue, if you're living in mold, if you have all these other things that are stressing the immune system out chronically, guess what? Your liver is also going to try to keep you in a sugar burning state because the body is trying to keep the immune system fueled.

11:48 Becca Chilczenkowski: And so this is why we approach healing from not only, yes, a, you know, gut and immune aspect, but from a metabolic aspect because they are delicately intertwined and you cannot have one without the other. And there are a lot of people that believe that truly metabolic disease is the underlying piece of all of it. Literally all of it. And so I think it's a little bit more nuanced than that personally, but it's why we work so hard on the metabolism, even in these people that maybe think like, well, my blood sugars are normal or, you know, I my A1C is a 5.0.

12:21 Becca Chilczenkowski: That does not mean that you have completely healthy metabolic flexibility. My A1C was a 4.9. I couldn't get into fat burning, I couldn't get into ketosis. So that is the type of person and that's like, right, the I was waking up at 430 in the morning to coach classes. I was doing two workouts a day. I was drinking protein shake after protein shake and eating protein bars. And then I became a mom trying to run a business, right. Like all of these different things inside the body, cortisol is it's the one that's controlling the show.

Why carbs and fat matter for cortisol and sleep

12:53 Liz Roman: Yeah. And I think, you know, so you mentioned obviously sleep, good quality sleep and having muscle mass. If you don't have a great quality diet that's diverse, you're not going to have the amino acids to build your muscle and you're going to have stable blood sugar to sleep. And so if something is off and you're doing a lot of things with your diet that are correct, you have to ask bigger, deeper questions, not just doing more of the same thing that's not working.

13:16 Liz Roman: And that's where I think people on the protein side take it too far, right, because they will just do protein every single meal without thinking about the diversity of their fats, without thinking about the adequate levels of carbohydrate that help lower cortisol. So this is something when you see and we have adrenal cocktail guide that I just finished and the sleepy time mocktail, people will be like, oh, tart cherry juice that's got so many carbohydrates and so much sugar.

13:46 Liz Roman: Well, yes, the recommendation is to pair it with something that's going to have fat with it. But the reason that it works so well, tart cherry juice is supportive of melatonin and naturally high in melatonin like pistachios, which are a fat source. Great to pair together, but it has some carbohydrates. Carbohydrates have an inverse relationship with cortisol. So if you are somebody training in the afternoon or you have trouble sleeping, this is where we say those blood sugar balancing snacks before bed can help you stabilize your sugar, because if you drop too low, your body again is going to create glucose through the process of gluconeogenesis, which is also, you know, another way that this process gets triggered beyond, you know, protein.

14:26 Liz Roman: So this is important. I think you need to have a diverse diet. I think that you need to, like you mentioned, go through seasons where you are intentionally getting into autophagy and you are intentionally in a feast famine cycle. That's how we were designed, right? Because all of this is going to help you with your inflammation.

Why calories in, calories out stops working

14:44 Liz Roman: And inflammation is what changes the rules. This changes how your body processes things and respond to the stressors in your life, to food. How does it and your gut plays a big role here in terms of the microbiome and certain bacteria that will extract more calories from food, even though you're eating the same things that you always did. But you notice I'm more bloated and I'm gaining weight outside of the cortisol picture, we have to ask what's happening in the gut? What bacteria here are maybe extracting more calories or what bacteria are you missing that would help you produce your natural GLP one activity in the gut? And so that's why calories in, calories out.

15:24 Liz Roman: We've talked about this so many times. For some people, it stops working. You can't answer the question why someone is eating 800 calories a day for months on end and losing or not losing weight. Maybe they're gaining weight. Well, that mathematically doesn't make sense. It is because of cortisol, how your body is going to perceive this information and that hormonal environment and the inflammatory environment that is going into and that will give you the different outcomes.

Why does perimenopause cause belly fat?

15:54 Liz Roman: So we also know perimenopause takes away the buffer dam when your hormones start to go offline. We call it the great unknown revealing or the highlighter of things that have been going on under the surface. So estrogen used to help make your insulin work, protect your muscle, keep fat on your hips instead of your belly. We also know cortisol has a lot of fat receptors in the belly and the hip area. And so during this transition, there's research to show that visceral fat, belly fat climbs 8.2% per year in the two years before the final period.

16:28 Liz Roman: Great. And lean mass shifts from slowly gaining to slowly losing. So insulin sensitivity declines during this transition, even after accounting for age and BMI. So the translation into this is what worked at 32 can backfire for you. At 44, you're in a different season of your life. I would also argue that this can change based upon major stressors and trauma and life events. So if you lost a loved one, you dealt with a severe illness, you had a pregnancy.

16:58 Liz Roman: Maybe it was a loss, maybe it was a birth. Either one is going to be taxing to the body. And so your body doesn't know the difference here. And if you think about it in your day to day, it doesn't know the difference between a lion chasing you and really fighting for your life. Or an email that you got this morning that totally set you off. Nervous system doesn't know the difference. I feel my nervous system get activated.

17:23 Liz Roman: Yesterday I got an email at 7 a.m. and I was like four letter word. Not what I want to deal with on a monday morning at 7 a.m. And I felt that adrenaline, the heart racing, the blood boiling kind of right. And then, you know, for many of you listen, perimenopause just didn't break your metabolism. It took away the buffer that's hiding your stress. And so I would encourage you to lean into that, to be curious, to ask questions, to take this information of symptoms and say, all right, I need to make some changes. I need to give my body something a little bit different and stop just assuming that doing more is going to give you a better outcome in terms of more workouts, more restriction.

18:04 Liz Roman: This calories in, calories out assumes that your hormones are neutral and in perimenopause, they are absolutely not.

Why you might not be digesting your protein

18:11 Liz Roman: So the last the last portion here is how do we even digest it? And I think there's some really cool research. I shared it in Dallas regarding up to 50% of your protein that you ingest can be lost because you're not properly digesting it.

18:29 Becca Chilczenkowski: And we know this female, right? Like she's working out five days a week. She's eating high protein, usually low carb, low fat. She tracks macros or she knows how many calories she's eating. She's super stressed. Some of them are eating protein through protein shakes and protein bars, but some of them are eating like whole foods eggs, chicken, fish, steak. Right. And by 3 p.m., they're bloated, feeling pregnant. By the time they go to bed, no matter what they eat. Right. So protein digestion is supposed to work with the stomach acid basically unfolds the protein and switches on pepsin. It's the enzyme that starts kind of cutting protein apart. Pepsin works best at a very acidic pH of about 1.5 to 2.

19:08 Becca Chilczenkowski: When that acidic food hits the small intestine, it signals the pancreas via secretin to release more protein digesting enzymes. Fat in the meal signals the gallbladder to release bile. Right. So stomach acid is not just one step. It's kind of the first domino in multiple then dominoes of the digestive tract. So stomach acid is the first piece. And if it does not fall, nothing after it will work. Right. And that's why even when you work on bile, you have to also work on stomach acid.

19:35 Becca Chilczenkowski: When you work on the small intestine and motility, you also have to work on stomach acid because it is the beginning of all of this. Right? Digestion is there's a reason that rest and digest is a phrase because you need to be in a parasympathetic state to be able to digest food. I was told a great little hack of like if you're not salivating before you eat, your body is not in a place where it is ready to digest that food. And so if you're like rushing in between meetings and you're in the car or you're standing up or all these things like take a beat, is your mouth salivating?

20:09 Becca Chilczenkowski: My mouth salivating right now, thinking about food. But do you have the capacity to even break down food right now? I mean, I'll be honest, there's many a times where I like shove food in my mouth standing in the kitchen, and then I'm like 30 minutes later, I'm like, why am I bloated? I'm like, Oh, I know why. I know I am bloated because I didn't give my body the chance to properly break down and digest these foods and it's run by the vagus nerve.

20:33 Becca Chilczenkowski: So even the first wave of stomach acid, the one triggered by seeing and smelling and tasting food, is entirely vagus, nerve driven. And so the stress system does the opposite. Obviously, it puts a brake on digestive secretions, fear. Oh, how much have we talked about? Like the concept of people that have chronic food sensitivities start to have fear before they even eat food, before they even put food in their mouth. I am going to react to this.

20:58 Becca Chilczenkowski: I'm constantly bloated. I don't digest things well and have created this like identity around it. It's going to be very hard to kind of fix the body's response unless you are aware of that. It is a piece of it is not just a digestive enzyme and stomach acid support. It is how you perceive your body's ability to tolerate the food. And so fun history fact back in 1833, a doctor watching a patient's stomach through an open wound noted acid secretion was affected by fear, anger and whatever depresses or disturbs the nervous system.

21:32 Becca Chilczenkowski: All the way back in the 1800s, guys like it hasn't changed. It's only gotten worse. So, you know, chugging a protein shake in the car while answering slack messages and, you know, yelling at your kids from the back because they're fighting like your body never got to see, smell, anticipate food. There's no rest or digest signal. And then we wonder why we feel bloated. It's just common sense.

How age, infections, and acid blockers drain stomach acid

21:59 Liz Roman: On top of that, you're not even making the connection that you're actually eating. I remember we podcasted on this. This is probably back in early 2021 or 2022. But in terms of calories, people consume more calories when they eat distracted because they don't make the connection that they've actually eaten. It doesn't register for them, you know, And so then they just continue later on in the day to eat and then crave sugar. And, you know, all the the chips and all that.

22:28 Liz Roman: So reason number two, and we'll kind of go through these quickly here age and we know that age doesn't help us. As we age, we lose stomach acid. So some of the stats are that if we look at the stomach acid levels of a 20 year old compared to a 40 year old, we lose like 40%. And so recent research suggest aging itself isn't the main cause, but it's also the accumulation of other infections. Right? So whether this is H. pylori, it could be gastritis, other GI, you know, microbial infections, acid blocking medications. [Editor's note: studies on age-related stomach acid decline are mixed, and the exact percentage varies by study. The point that follows, that infections and medications drive much of the loss, reflects current evidence.]

23:00 Liz Roman: So this is reason number three and it's huge when you are taking a proton pump inhibitors. So omeprazole, Pepcid, whatever. There's a several of them and you can even get them like at the store Pepcid and all of those types of things. These are designed to lower acid and they do long term use will put that stomach around 5 to 7. Pepsin activity drops to under 5% when it is above a five. Pepsin is what we need to break down protein.

23:29 Liz Roman: And in one study, after just one month, four weeks, on omeprazole protein absorption was impaired and markers of protein fermenting in the colon went up. So even though the pamphlet says a proton pump inhibitors should only be used, short term, people are left on it for years and they are not provided the informed consent of the damage that this can have. They I've said this 100 times, but I'm going to say it again if you've not heard me a really good book, why Stomach acid is Good for You.

24:02 Liz Roman: He opens the book with the story of the Pale Man, the white man. He calls him. I believe, but he was so pale because he was so fragile, so nutrient depleted. And not only that, but people don't feel well eating protein, so they stop eating protein and ingesting it. Right. Again, it's one thing to ingest it, it's another thing to digest it. So if you started a PPI for reflux, let's say, and again you thought it's just going to be for a week, a few weeks.

24:29 Liz Roman: But yeah, you've been on it for years because you can't get off of it. You're feeling worse when you try to increase your protein. Of course you do, because you turn out the protein and turn down the very thing that helps you actually digest it. So it sits there like a brick and then other bugs ferment on it and now you're bloated and distended and gassy. So of course, don't stop PPIs on your own, right?

24:51 Liz Roman: We want to make sure that we are slowly weaning people down at the same time supporting them to rebuild their stomach acid so that they can actually digest and absorb their nutrients. And another huge thing with stomach acid is triggering bile. So we have to look at not only the intake of your fat.

Does a low-fat diet affect your gallbladder?

25:10 Liz Roman: Low fat over the years has equated to more gallbladder removals and it equals sluggish bile. So more peanut butter like bile compared to fluid. So your gallbladder needs fat as a signal to squeeze. That's the thing that tells it to construct and release. Bile Research has shown on very low fat diets. About ten grams of fat in a meal was the threshold for good gallbladder emptying In a study of rapid weight loss, gallstones developed in four of six people on a diet with under two grams of fat a day and none in the people who are eating 30 grams a day, skipping meals and long fast also reduce our gallbladder contractions.

25:47 Liz Roman: So egg whites, chicken breast fat, free Greek yogurt, fat free. Everything that we were told in the nineties may help you with your macros. I'm so happy that I don't have to sit here and change my avocado 28 grams to 35 grams because oh my gosh, it might be, you know, put me over the edge. We have to think about your gallbladder and especially when estrogen is fluctuating, keeping that bile flowing fluidly because estrogen dominance and low estrogen, it's a double edged sword here, impacts your bile negatively.

26:23 Liz Roman: So we want to make sure that we are supporting our body properly, to break down our proteins to support the pancreas with different digestive enzymes, to help us with nutrients across the board and bile, because bile will also not only help you break down all of those proteins, it will help clean your small intestine so that you're not ending up with bacteria fermenting there in the small intestine and resulting in bloating and gas. We see this a lot pregnancy, postpartum, large estrogen swings.

26:53 Liz Roman: We also see it when people have gone low fat for long periods of time. They're very stressed out. They're very nutrient depleted and they're not getting the proper signals that they need. Or even, for example, just on the dehydration aspect, they're not drinking adequate levels of water to even have bile be supported by those 95% water. And I know you add the same thing, back up with your intake forms. People come in and they're complaining of fatigue and brain fog and dry skin and constipation, and yet their water intake is maybe 30 to 40 ounces. So I would really aim to get about, I always say three liters to one gallon, depending upon your size, maybe a little less, a little more.

27:31 Liz Roman: But most importantly, put in electrolytes there because you need that hydration to properly build these gastric juices.

Signs your protein isn't breaking down

27:38 Becca Chilczenkowski: Yeah, because also when protein doesn't break down upstream, it then reaches the colon. Right. Bacteria will ferment. It produces gas, produces hydrogen sulfide, ammonia, other byproducts that not only irritate the gut lining, but they create that rotten egg smell, right? High protein, low carb diets shift the gut towards fermentation, and adding fiber and resistant starch helps to shift it back. You all. When I was drinking protein shakes all the time and like eating all the high protein things, I had the worst gas, the worst.

28:07 Becca Chilczenkowski: It was so bad. And I mean, I was not the healthiest person in the world. I was training to compete at a very high level and there were a lot of things that were wrong that I was completely ignoring because I didn't know any better at the time. But I absolutely dealt with that. Huh? Everyone knows the protein farts. Everyone knows there is a reason that it has a term. So if your gas smells like rotten eggs and you're on high protein, like not a flex, it's undigested protein that's reaching the colon and it's fermenting and you got to break it down. So if you are like bloated or heavy within 30 to 60 minutes, post a high protein meal, Foods feels like it sits in your stomach for hours burping, reflux, sulfur, rotten eggs, smelling gas, nausea after fatty meals, low ferritin or B12.

28:50 Becca Chilczenkowski: Despite a decent diet, you feel better on shakes versus like steak, right? You can't break down the tougher, more dense proteins. All of those are signs that protein digestion is absolutely something that probably needs help. And so the biggest thing is the low protein, right? We were talking about that in the beginning when I was going through this.

Becca's low-protein reset: why she couldn't get into ketosis

29:10 Becca Chilczenkowski: I came from a history of macros, 170 grams of protein a day, like it was a lot, right? And I could not get inflammation off. We were tracking ketones, we were tracking blood sugars. Ketones are basically is your body flipping into fat burning? Is it using ketones as an energy source? I was doing fasting, I was eating keto but with about 80 grams of protein a day. I could not get any ketosis.

29:37 Becca Chilczenkowski: My ketone numbers were like 0.2 to 0.3 even after like an 18 hour fast, 20 hour fast. And so I had to go through a period where it was very high fat, low protein. I'm talking less than 10 to 15 grams a day. I had to go Monday through Friday. I got to higher protein keto days on the weekends as like a little bit of a feed. And I ran that for about four weeks and it is when I saw the bigger shift in terms of inflammation fell off. I felt so much better and during this time I tracked my muscle mass, so I tracked my muscle mass using my Withings scale, which again like it's not perfect, right? It's an impedance scale.

30:15 Becca Chilczenkowski: It you know, you stand on it, it sends the electro field through you and like measures water and all that stuff. But my muscle mass actually went up. I was able to work out still. Was I maxing out lifts? No, of course not. But I was able to train and not feel awful. And I actually gained muscle because my body got metabolically better at using energy. Remember what we talked about earlier? If your body is not in a metabolically healthy state, it will break down your muscle to create amino acids and utilize it as sugar.

30:45 Becca Chilczenkowski: That is what can happen regardless of eating enough protein and training and doing all the things right that you think are right. I couldn't metabolically flip back and forth. I was stuck in sugar burning, which is why, regardless of how hard I trained trying to go into calorie deficits, do all the things I wasn't getting results. It took whipping, taking protein away, taking that energy source of the body was using away for a period of time to sensitize my body.

31:11 Becca Chilczenkowski: That was very stuck. And now my body goes back and forth pretty well. Last week I decided to just throw on an 18 hour fast. My ketones were 0.8 and I felt fine. And so like one, I had been eating really high carb leading into that too. I didn't even have to do keto prior to it to kind of ease the body into it. Like my body flipped like the day before I was at 2.2 ketones. I'm not sure if I trusted the keto mode or that day, but it's there, right?

31:36 Becca Chilczenkowski: And so like it's not that you have to do this constantly. A lot of times it's having to re sensitize the body initially and then the body is a lot better at going back and forth. If you do these little periods of fasting like this was talking about these little autophagy stents right throughout the year and kind of keep the sensitivity that the body then develops. Right. And so it is very short term, it is intentional and it is monitored.

31:57 Becca Chilczenkowski: That's how we do this with our clients. I'm not telling you guys to go and eat keto with ten grams of protein a day. Like you have to know that it's working and you have to watch for it. And then even more importantly, because everyone knows this, walking out of it properly because it's great and well, when you lose 10 in a month because your body drops all this inflammation, but then you decide to walk out of it like just go back to normal eating and then it all comes back on because we didn't ease the body out of it and expose it and keep in a tiny bit of fasting here and there as you walk the body out of it and be smart, which is what we do with our clients and how you got to be smart with it. Like there is a, there is a method to the madness here and everybody's system is different.

32:40 Becca Chilczenkowski: And so that's what I had to go through and what a lot of clients have to go through sometimes because the body just gets really metabolically stuck.

How to do a protein reset safely

32:48 Liz Roman: Yeah, and I think if you are somebody who is interested in trying this on yourself, like you mentioned, get the data, get a Keto-Mojo, get something so that you can track this. Oftentimes I will use these days when I see someone's blood sugar is elevated and there's no reason for it in regards to they've done a lot of the work. They're doing the things in the gym, they're walking, they're sleeping, they're hydrated, all of that.

33:11 Liz Roman: And it's like, okay, we need to go through a period of either a deeper fast protein sparing fast, which is fast mimicking. There's a lot of ways to slice this pie, but you have to know the data points in order to know if it's working. So definitely get that and then recognize that this is not a long term thing. We absolutely recognize the importance of protein and amino acids. You need it to build T for, you know, you need it to build your muscle, you need it to build hormones.

33:40 Liz Roman: You absolutely don't want to be in this place long term and walk in, walk out slowly, see how you do. But you have to commit to this process. You can't just be like, Oh, well, I listen to this podcast and I did a low protein for a day and that gave me the right to eat, you know, cheese pizza. Well, I guess you would still have protein there, but you know what I mean, like cookies or cake or crackers or whatever, like you're going to do it and, you know, low protein days.

34:04 Liz Roman: I was sharing this with a couple of the practitioners yesterday. I'm like, there's a lot of ways that you can eat meals. Like for me, I did a lot of the just veggie fajita style dinners when I would build a bowl like a burrito ball and I would just leave the protein out, but I had to watch and monitor the other, you know, fat sources and carbs, too. So there's ways to do it. It's not long term. It should be short term and you should be able to maintain that flexibility switch as long as you're doing all of the other foundations.

34:34 Liz Roman: So anything else that you want to add here I don't think we need to cover.

How much protein do you actually need?

34:38 Liz Roman: Regarding how much protein do you actually need guys, this is pretty simple math 0.8 to 1 gram per pound of your body weight. In general, if you are in the gym strength training, I think many people you can get away with 100, maybe 120 grams depending upon their size and all that. You have to go up to 150 eating 150 grams of protein every day all the time. I think there can be some, you know, get a little bit of excessive with some of that.

35:05 Liz Roman: But look and track outside of your blood sugars like pick a mentioned track with a body fat scanner you know and in body can be a great way or DEXA scan or any of those types of things and see where you're at and recognize that protein could be the villain. You just haven't considered it yet.

35:24 Becca Chilczenkowski: Yeah, absolutely. And again, this is different for everyone, right? Like if you're 180 of pure muscle, you probably will need a little bit more protein than someone that is 130 and like 28% body fat. Right? So this is always individualized and protein doesn't build muscle by itself. Guys, I feel like I shouldn't have to say that, but I'm going to say it. You need to lift weights. Protein is the material, right? Lifting weights creates the resources for the protein that can be utilized. And so we need to be looking at everything. But again, a 1200 calorie diet with 130 grams of protein. Right. Like you're not eating a high protein diet, you're eating a low calorie diet and you're starving yourself.

36:08 Becca Chilczenkowski: So just because it's high protein doesn't make it okay and doesn't make it better. So I would recommend that if you don't already track your food, figure out how much you're eating consistently, figure out if it's balanced and if you're struggling with a lot of these symptoms like we talked about in terms of not breaking food down, eating, doing everything right and still struggling, our link is in the show notes to schedule a call. We work with these cases a lot.

36:31 Becca Chilczenkowski: This is a lot of a piece of what we see with weight loss resistance cases and what we see with a lot of immunologically dysregulated too is there is a metabolic component to it. So link is in the show notes and we'll see you guys on the next one.

Frequently asked questions

Can eating too much protein make you gain weight?

Not directly. Protein is a building material, not a fat-loss fix. FitMom's practitioners see weight gain on high-protein diets when protein is paired with chronic stress, under-eating, very low carbs and fat, or poor digestion. In that state cortisol keeps the liver making sugar, insulin stays elevated, and belly fat and muscle loss follow. Fix the stress and fuel picture first, then set protein to what you can actually digest.

Does protein turn into sugar in your body?

It can, through gluconeogenesis: the liver building new glucose from amino acids, lactate, and glycerol. In a calm, well-fed body the effect is small. In a 2013 labeled-egg study, only about 4 of the 50 grams of glucose produced over 8 hours came from 23 grams of egg protein. Cortisol, insulin resistance, fasting, and very low-carb eating turn that dial up.

Why am I gaining weight on a high-protein diet when I barely eat?

Calorie math assumes your hormones are neutral, and in a stressed or perimenopausal body they aren't. Becca Chilczenkowski of FitMom explains that when food doesn't supply enough fuel, cortisol pulls amino acids from muscle and turns them into sugar. A 1,200-calorie day with 130 grams of protein is a low-calorie diet, not a high-protein one, and the body responds by holding on.

How does cortisol cause muscle loss?

Cortisol switches on the liver's sugar-making enzymes and breaks down muscle to supply the amino acids they need. Under chronic stress (poor sleep, 5 a.m. workouts on caffeine, under-eating, gut infections, mold), more amino acids leave muscle and become glucose. That's how a woman can hit her protein target, train hard, and still lose muscle while belly fat climbs.

Why am I bloated after eating protein?

Usually the protein isn't being broken down upstream. Digestion starts with stomach acid, which unfolds protein and activates pepsin, an enzyme that works best at a pH of about 1.5 to 2. Low acid from stress, eating on the run, H. pylori, or acid blockers leaves protein sitting like a brick while bacteria ferment it into gas. Liz Roman of FitMom calls it the difference between ingesting and digesting.

Why does my gas smell like rotten eggs on a high-protein diet?

Rotten-egg gas usually means undigested protein is reaching the colon, where bacteria ferment it into hydrogen sulfide, ammonia, and other byproducts that irritate the gut lining. Becca Chilczenkowski of FitMom lists the other signs: heaviness 30 to 60 minutes after a protein meal, burping, reflux, nausea after fatty meals, low ferritin or B12, and feeling better on shakes than on steak.

Do acid blockers like PPIs affect protein digestion?

Yes. Proton pump inhibitors raise stomach pH to roughly 5 to 7, where pepsin, the main protein-digesting enzyme, is largely inactive. A 1998 study found impaired protein assimilation and more colonic protein fermentation in healthy people after omeprazole. FitMom's practitioners never have clients stop PPIs abruptly. They wean slowly alongside the prescriber while rebuilding stomach acid.

How much protein do women actually need?

It depends on muscle mass, training, and digestion. Liz Roman's working range on the episode is 0.8 to 1 gram per pound of body weight, and many strength-training women do well around 100 to 120 grams a day. Becca Chilczenkowski adds that protein doesn't build muscle by itself, lifting does, and recommends tracking body composition, not just grams, to see whether it's working.

Is a short-term low-protein reset safe?

Only when it's short, intentional, and monitored. FitMom's practitioners use brief protein-restricted phases, often 48 to 72 hours followed by refeeds, for clients whose metabolism is stuck in sugar-burning despite good habits. They track blood sugar, ketones, and body composition, then ease out slowly. Becca Chilczenkowski ran a monitored four-week version and her measured muscle mass went up. It is not a DIY plan.

Bloated after every protein meal?

Low stomach acid, sluggish bile, and a stuck stress response all show up on the right labs. Apply and we'll look at the data with you.

Apply for a Root Cause Discovery Call

Key terms

Gluconeogenesis
The liver (and to a lesser extent the kidneys) making new glucose from non-sugar sources: amino acids from protein, plus lactate and glycerol from fat breakdown.
Cortisol
The main stress hormone. It raises blood sugar, switches on the liver's sugar-making enzymes, and breaks down muscle to supply amino acids for them.
Insulin resistance
When cells stop responding well to insulin. Insulin normally shuts gluconeogenesis off after a meal; with resistance, the liver keeps making sugar anyway.
Pepsin
The stomach enzyme that starts cutting protein apart. It needs a very acidic stomach, around pH 1.5 to 2, to work.
Proton pump inhibitor (PPI)
An acid-blocking medication such as omeprazole. Labeled for short-term use, but often taken for years.
Bile
Fluid made by the liver and released by the gallbladder when fat is eaten. It helps digest fat and protein and helps keep the small intestine clean.
Metabolic flexibility
The body's ability to switch between burning sugar and burning fat (ketones). Losing it means being stuck in sugar-burning.
Ketones
Fuel the body makes from fat when it shifts into fat-burning. Blood ketone readings show whether that shift is actually happening.
Visceral fat
Fat stored around the abdominal organs. SWAN research shows it accelerates in the two years before the final menstrual period.
Autophagy
The body's cellular clean-up process, encouraged by periods of fasting or lower intake.

Sources

Educational content from FitMom's practitioners. Not medical advice. Don't stop prescribed medication, including PPIs, without your prescriber.